Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gabriel Weston's avatar

I really enjoyed the philosophical nature of this essay. It’s made me question how much I actually chose to pick up my phone at 6.30 in the morning…though your piece has justified the impulse.

Juliette Ryan's avatar

With uncanny timing, I found myself reading this minutes after finishing an essay about how the “check-phone” and “scroll” programs get wired into our striatum (based on over 1000 logged urges from people who have rewired those programs).

I love how you question where “you” are in all this. The brain is a crafty thing, able to manufacture thoughts wrapped in the same language networks your “deliberate” thoughts use in an attempt to resolve a conflict between what your striatum says should happen (check phone) and what your prefrontal cortex has decreed (do not!). In that battle, the striatum usually wins. (It’s got desire dopamine on its side, after all.)

You seem to have arrived at the same realisation I did, though I needed a hefty dose of science to get there. You have used hours of meditation, philosophy and introspection (which I think is far more impressive), and it is always such a pleasure to read.

Phone Free Will might have to be renamed to Free Will in due course :).

16 more comments...

Keep reading

View all