Reinstalling Instagram
Using the deepest wisdom to solve the most banal problem ever
I’ve been commuting without a phone for nearly eleven months. But the most interesting conversation was in the first week.
A woman on the train told me about how she had deleted the Instagram app, and then given her phone passwords to her mum. Yet a few days later she had called her up, got them back, and reinstalled Instagram.
To say she was disappointed with herself was an understatement. As she told the story she seemed at once resigned, crestfallen and confused.
A few years back I was making progress with my phone use. I followed all the advice out there. I deleted my most troublesome apps. I installed a powerful blocking app. I had the phone problem sorted.
Until one evening when I very deliberately and very consciously undid all that and took myself back to square one.
Let’s remember what was at stake. I had made my daughter cry by looking at my phone too much. Now I was willingly going back to its embrace.
A lot of the ways we describe this dilemma - saying the phone is addictive - are really just to restate the problem.
And conventional phone advice has very little to say on it. After all, if you willingly and consciously go against the advice, what is there to say?
At this point people conclude one of three things. That deep down they don’t want to stop using the phone. That it is impossible. Or even that they are a bad person.
All of which point you towards giving up. People accept the phone will eat up a decent chunk of their free time. Of their life. I suspect there’s a less obvious effect too - a grim outlook, and all the downsides I try to describe in these posts.
It wasn’t until six years after the ballet disaster that I came to believe I had solved this mystery.
Weirdly it happened as a result of reading a lot of philosophy and doing a lot of meditation.
I’m not evangelical about any of this stuff. You don’t have to believe me to find it helpful. What I hope is that it all makes for a fresh perspective on phones.
Throw in the high vis, and I think we can safely say “unique”.
No-One Cares About My Awakening
As I’ve mentioned a few times here, at a certain point in meditation I experienced what I can only describe as a moment of awakening.
And frankly I’ve been disappointed at how no-one seems to be impressed.
After trying my family and my friends (I got a “that’s great, mate”) I kind of left it there.
It’s really hard to explain. It flickers between ridiculous sounding and utterly obvious.
But but but. I do think there is something really valuable here. Despite my son making fun of me by asking if I can generate a fireball like Ryu from Street Fighter. Or my wife asking when my newfound wisdom will mean I will stop eating the cheese straight from the fridge, without using a knife or a plate.
Although there’s no agreed definition, the way I talk about this is in line with various bits of ancient wisdom and also modern thinkers, particularly the neuroscientist and author Sam Harris.
Any mangling of these ideas is my fault.
As is my obsession with using this profound inner knowledge to explain why I keep uninstalling and installing apps.
The Autosteer Moment
I am conscious. I have a sense of what it’s like to be me. That sense, I believe, is generated by my brain and body.
I also believe my brain and body generate all my thoughts, feelings and actions.
It’s how all this inter-relates that’s the problem. It’s about the connection between the feeling of being me and how I act.
Most people believe that the conscious me is in charge. The conscious self receives information and then in real time decides how to act. They feel there is an “inner me” directing thoughts and actions. Because that is how it feels.
But that sense of the conscious self being in control is no longer how it feels to me. After a lot of meditation, it now feels to me that actions, thoughts and feelings arise without the “inner me” authoring them.
They originate, I believe, within my brain and body - not from the cosmos or anything outside.
But the sense that the conscious me is authoring them is a kind of overlay, a manufactured feeling accompanying them. And this is the case for ALL thoughts - there isn’t some special wise “me” that observes other thoughts. That is just a thought too.
It’s a bit like you are driving a car with autosteer, and you are merrily moving the steering wheel around and believing you are steering, but actually the car is driving itself.
As far as I understand it, this is perfectly consistent with neuroscience. It seems likely that the physical brain generates conscious thoughts. After all, if I drink three pints then my conscious thoughts change.
But unfortunately science can’t settle the role of the conscious “inner me” definitively, because - despite some interesting experiments - there is no scientific explanation for how and why we are conscious.
Thinking About Dogs
Meditators like me believe that the best evidence comes from watching our own minds.
A quick experiment.
Close your eyes and think about dogs. Everything about them, for as long as you can.
After a while, you’ll notice you aren’t thinking about dogs. Some other thought just popped up and took over.
Where did that come from? And who chose it?
It might be a perfectly logical thought. It might be irritation at this stupid game. It might be something you need to do. Or it might be totally left field - honestly I just did this and ice cream popped into my head. In November.
But the point is that *you* were supposed to be thinking about dogs, and some part of your brain changed the channel. *You* weren’t the author of the new thought.
I would argue that this is a rare moment of paying attention to the process of thinking. Most of the time it goes unobserved, and so the conscious mind’s automatic overlay of authorship is never challenged.
Meditators like me believe that if we practise every day paying attention to a chosen focus, and notice our mind wandering, it becomes more and more evident that all thoughts just appear.
In all my meditation, I never saw where they were coming from, and different people hold different beliefs on this. But I was pretty clear they weren’t coming from conscious authorship - that feeling was a fib.
If exercises like this are repeated daily, the brain increasingly sees new thoughts as having just arisen - including the recognition of this fact.
(This is hopelessly compressed. If you’re interested in understanding what all this felt like, the day in which it flipped - and how I still managed to get to dinner on time - read here.)
Enter The Phone
What does this mean for phones?
Let’s imagine this is right, that thoughts are generated by the brain and just pop up in consciousness.
These thoughts are likely the result of my brain taking in information from the outside world, cross-referencing it with all my memories and then generating something new as a result.
Thanks to unseen processing, the brain sees light bouncing off something, it turns it into colour, it cross-references with memory and it becomes a parakeet flying past the window, which reminds you that you have a holiday booked, which reminds you how bad you are at your job, which reminds you to check LinkedIn to see how much cleverer your peers are than you.
The raw data - light bouncing off objects, vibrations in the air - can’t be perceived. The brain puts its spin on it all, thanks to memories and a series of tendencies likely shaped by evolution: to stay alive, to look after our children, to work in a team etc.
I argued in this post that because the phone is infinitely adaptable and available to us 24/7, it can constantly evolve to indulge all our psychological needs. Soon enough, a huge proportion of brain processing ends in a thought to use the phone.
Of course the brain isn’t fixed. Neuroscientists have tracked how it changes with usage. An old adage is “what fires together, wires together”. You’ve likely heard of the study of London taxi drivers whose learning of the A to Z had gone hand in hand with structural changes to their brain.
My brain has likely done that for picking up the phone. Because it’s done it a lot, it’s rewired itself around doing it all the time.
And the brain expresses itself in relevant conscious thoughts. It doesn’t say “eat”, it says “Ooo I think I will add two packets of Cheese Strings to the Sainsbury’s shop”.
And so my rewired brain doesn’t make me pick the phone up by barking “Use the phone” in a Ray Winstone-style order. It cross-references the phone impulse with memory and comes up with a million reasons in every quiet moment.
Each of these reasons aren’t just convincing. They are my conscious thoughts. They feel like my ideas. They feel like I author them. In any given moment it makes perfect sense to pick up the phone.
But look back over screen time for a week and you think oh. Oh. I really wanted to read a book in that time.
Or you look at a busy train carriage and you think gosh. Something weird is happening here.
Nothing about what I’ve said changes the way we perceive other people’s thoughts and actions. We are usually pretty good at that.
(That guy looks at his phone a lot.)
It is our perception of ourselves, of our inner life and decision making that is wrong.
(I’ll just check my emails quickly again.)
Why Resolutions Fail
Let us imagine a hypothetical man whose brain has rewired itself around the propensity to pick up the phone very often.
We find him outside his front door. On the face of it he has gone outside to sort the bins. In reality, hypothetically, he is watching a video on Reddit about the lift in the Eiffel Tower.
Let’s imagine his hypothetical wife appears because he has been gone a surprising amount of time. She is unimpressed.
That man, then and there, resolves he will stop looking at the phone all the time.
But that is just a thought. Because he has a false confidence in the conscious self being in charge, he falsely believes this decision carries weight. He is very much wrong.
We can see inside his brain, as he stands by those bins, and it’s still fully wired to keep checking the phone. That one thought alone didn’t change that.
So he keeps on.
Let’s imagine that later this hypothetical man makes his hypothetical daughter cry by looking at the phone during her ballet recital.
Then he might get more serious and turn to self-help advice. Self-help advice would recognise much of the above and tell him about the wiring. It would say that resolution by the bins would never work on its own. It would advise him to do all sorts of things to slow his phone usage. Put the phone in another room. Set up app blockers. All that.
The self-help book would be confident that it would work, because the app blockers would stop instinctive phone pickups and engage the conscious mind. By putting up a barrier to phone use, the barrier wakes up higher reasoning, all that. And the conscious self that is fighting the phone will take control, know better and stop using the thing.
But here’s where our argument begs to differ. Conscious thought is great but it ain’t as special as we make it out to be. It feels like a fixed unchanging self, capable of carrying a resolution through. But actually it’s just a succession of thoughts. One thought is “I shouldn’t use the phone so much”. But over time thoughts born of ingrained habits will win out. Like “Wait a minute I need Reddit back to find that video about the dog because my daughter will like it”.
So sooner or later the man undoes all the changes - entirely consciously. And he deletes the app blockers. And willingly reinstalls Reddit.
And then in another mood he looks at a video he happens to have of his daughter crying at the ballet recital. And he wonders if he is a bad person.
As he keeps on scrolling.
Comfort
This sounds bleak. It feels like a one step forward two steps back kind of thing. Read an article about phone fiddling, lose both sense of self and free will.
But there is a way out. Before we get there though, there’s a really important point.
The real problem with believing in the power of conscious thought is this: if you believe you are in control, then when you return to bad habits consciously, it defeats you. You can only conclude that you are a bad person, that deep down you want to do it, and it’s impossible to change.
All conclusions that encourage you to stop trying.
But if the argument I’m making holds, then none of the above is true. You aren’t bad, it was entirely predictable. You aren’t acting on “deeper desires”, just ingrained ones. And it isn’t impossible to change, because the brain can clearly be rewired over time.
The illusion of conscious authorship has unhelpfully given us misplaced confidence that we can escape easily, and then self-blame when we fail.
So at the point of failure, this argument goes, self-recrimination is a waste of time.
I wish I could have said all this to the woman on the train. She might have found it interesting. But I would have needed three quarters of an hour. And it might not have come over well, what with me wearing high vis.
The conversation ended awkwardly, and we both watched all the other passengers on their phones. I wondered if she was going to try again or give up.
Those moments of clarity - when you look around at a world of people glued to their phones, when you look over weeks of your own phone time - are still valuable. But the lesson from all this isn’t that you should redouble your resolve. Instead you should make a fresh plan to retrain yourself.
You should continue the fight.
Even as it’s less clear who “you” is.
Next week: what all this waffle actually means in practice.
Thank you! If you enjoyed this, please consider sharing.
Confused as to what all this 1,000 hours of nothing business is about? Start here.


I really enjoyed the philosophical nature of this essay. It’s made me question how much I actually chose to pick up my phone at 6.30 in the morning…though your piece has justified the impulse.
With uncanny timing, I found myself reading this minutes after finishing an essay about how the “check-phone” and “scroll” programs get wired into our striatum (based on over 1000 logged urges from people who have rewired those programs).
I love how you question where “you” are in all this. The brain is a crafty thing, able to manufacture thoughts wrapped in the same language networks your “deliberate” thoughts use in an attempt to resolve a conflict between what your striatum says should happen (check phone) and what your prefrontal cortex has decreed (do not!). In that battle, the striatum usually wins. (It’s got desire dopamine on its side, after all.)
You seem to have arrived at the same realisation I did, though I needed a hefty dose of science to get there. You have used hours of meditation, philosophy and introspection (which I think is far more impressive), and it is always such a pleasure to read.
Phone Free Will might have to be renamed to Free Will in due course :).