I really enjoyed the philosophical nature of this essay. It’s made me question how much I actually chose to pick up my phone at 6.30 in the morning…though your piece has justified the impulse.
With uncanny timing, I found myself reading this minutes after finishing an essay about how the “check-phone” and “scroll” programs get wired into our striatum (based on over 1000 logged urges from people who have rewired those programs).
I love how you question where “you” are in all this. The brain is a crafty thing, able to manufacture thoughts wrapped in the same language networks your “deliberate” thoughts use in an attempt to resolve a conflict between what your striatum says should happen (check phone) and what your prefrontal cortex has decreed (do not!). In that battle, the striatum usually wins. (It’s got desire dopamine on its side, after all.)
You seem to have arrived at the same realisation I did, though I needed a hefty dose of science to get there. You have used hours of meditation, philosophy and introspection (which I think is far more impressive), and it is always such a pleasure to read.
Phone Free Will might have to be renamed to Free Will in due course :).
I really look forward to reading it! It's been fascinating to read about your Rewiring programme - I'll bet you must be capturing some really interesting data (along with helping people in a novel way). Sounds like such a great and creative way to tackle those pesky urges.
I'm nowhere near as expert on the neuroscience as you, but have read a little about which bits of the brain might be doing what. Having had hundreds of hours with nothing to do you'd almost think by now higher reasoning and a stupid urge would feel somehow different... but they stubbornly do not! They both seem likely perfectly well-reasoned ideas in the moment.
Thank you for your kind words. I doubt very much I could have got to the realisation point without reading the philosophy. I've read of lots of people who have fallen backwards into it, but it felt to me that I needed all that surrounding reading, even as the moment itself just happened in silence on a normal day.
And yes! I was playing round with names earlier in the year and got so excited by the Free Will pun that I couldn't resist it. But get so many comments pointing out I have a phone. Maybe need to look at that one :-)
A banger of a piece. It’s wild how the brain plays tricks on itself to get what it wants even though it knows it’s bad for itself. I know you don’t read on the train, either, but (god I can’t believe I’m about to be the guy who recommends…) Infinite Jest’s best moments revolve around the author’s understanding of addiction. I think a lot of it jives with what you’re saying here. Basically everybody in the book is addicted to something, and the big bad weapon is a piece of entertainment so entertaining you can’t stop watching till you die.
Thank you! And thank you, added to the list, and looking forward to it.
One of the slight downsides of my ridiculous scheme is to sharply reduce available reading time to the half hour before bed. And now the kids are up later - and my son needs defeating on Super Smash Bros - that time itself is getting squeezed.
I'm going to have to write more pro-doing nothing anti-reading pieces to create a high-flown justification for my ignorance.
Hi Will, Thank you for the clarity of your words to help us all fathom managing phone usage. As much as it can be a creative tool and many of us need instagram as a business card/portfolio etc it kills our creativity in many ways.
My big question is - do you manage to meditate without using an app?
Fully sympathise. I have given a lot of thought to ditching the smartphone but I really don't think it's compatible with the demands of my job. I am fortunate to not need to be onInstagram, but have many friends for whom that's the case and I can only imagine how difficult it is to balance.
Yes, I now meditate without an app.
I guess it depends what type of meditation you're going for. I know a lot of people enjoy those body scan / relaxation meditations, and I've always felt that it's much easier to do that while listening to something guided.
If you're going for the "focus on something, notice mind wander, return to focus" kind of meditation (which was my favourite) then from the start I just used ambient sound and a timer on my watch. Though sometimes I experimented with using clanging noises played via the phone, which helped in certain environments. Then after a few months I switched to the breath as focus.
In the early days I listened to a course by Jeff Warren on Calm, but I kind of used that for information, a little like listening to an audiobook.
Thank you for writing this Substack! Ive enjoyed following your journey. I've been inspired by you to take on a nuclear option: leaving my smartphone off for hours at a time and just checking every few hours, then immediately shutting off. Since I'm a parent I have an emergency dumb phone on at all time as an emergency back up.
People think I'm crazy having two phones, but when you are going up against Silicon Valley Phds working to addict you, you need extreme solutions.
Absolutely fascinating - I really hope it works for you. Would genuinely love to hear - please let me know.
I'm a huge fan of this kind of approach - I once heard it described as intermittent digital fasting. Not only does it have super clear rules, I also suspect it gives the head time to clear which might result in 24/7 benefits in mood (with a little luck). Really hope it goes well.
I am certain it's not crazy. If self-control worked with phones, well.... well let's face it, it doesn't.
NB I accept it may not be much comfort to be told you're not crazy by someone who wears high vis :-)
I enjoy all your posts, but if some calamity were to come upon us all and I could help avert it by just picking one favourite, it would be this one. It is a vipassana post of the highest order, exquisitely formulated and yet accessible. Which btw is really difficult to do from the other side of any sort of awakening.
This is hugely appreciated. Honestly such a lovely comment to receive. Thank you.
And thank you for the last point too - I can see why people say things like "Just be", because that kind of is the whole thing. But that's no help, is it? And where is the fun in it? :-D
I really enjoyed the philosophical nature of this essay. It’s made me question how much I actually chose to pick up my phone at 6.30 in the morning…though your piece has justified the impulse.
Thank you so much for reading!
I'm pretty sure nothing is me until I have had two cups of coffee.
With uncanny timing, I found myself reading this minutes after finishing an essay about how the “check-phone” and “scroll” programs get wired into our striatum (based on over 1000 logged urges from people who have rewired those programs).
I love how you question where “you” are in all this. The brain is a crafty thing, able to manufacture thoughts wrapped in the same language networks your “deliberate” thoughts use in an attempt to resolve a conflict between what your striatum says should happen (check phone) and what your prefrontal cortex has decreed (do not!). In that battle, the striatum usually wins. (It’s got desire dopamine on its side, after all.)
You seem to have arrived at the same realisation I did, though I needed a hefty dose of science to get there. You have used hours of meditation, philosophy and introspection (which I think is far more impressive), and it is always such a pleasure to read.
Phone Free Will might have to be renamed to Free Will in due course :).
I really look forward to reading it! It's been fascinating to read about your Rewiring programme - I'll bet you must be capturing some really interesting data (along with helping people in a novel way). Sounds like such a great and creative way to tackle those pesky urges.
I'm nowhere near as expert on the neuroscience as you, but have read a little about which bits of the brain might be doing what. Having had hundreds of hours with nothing to do you'd almost think by now higher reasoning and a stupid urge would feel somehow different... but they stubbornly do not! They both seem likely perfectly well-reasoned ideas in the moment.
Thank you for your kind words. I doubt very much I could have got to the realisation point without reading the philosophy. I've read of lots of people who have fallen backwards into it, but it felt to me that I needed all that surrounding reading, even as the moment itself just happened in silence on a normal day.
And yes! I was playing round with names earlier in the year and got so excited by the Free Will pun that I couldn't resist it. But get so many comments pointing out I have a phone. Maybe need to look at that one :-)
Wonderful piece Will and very inspiring. 🙏
Thank you for taking the time to say so! Really glad you enjoyed it.
A banger of a piece. It’s wild how the brain plays tricks on itself to get what it wants even though it knows it’s bad for itself. I know you don’t read on the train, either, but (god I can’t believe I’m about to be the guy who recommends…) Infinite Jest’s best moments revolve around the author’s understanding of addiction. I think a lot of it jives with what you’re saying here. Basically everybody in the book is addicted to something, and the big bad weapon is a piece of entertainment so entertaining you can’t stop watching till you die.
Thank you! And thank you, added to the list, and looking forward to it.
One of the slight downsides of my ridiculous scheme is to sharply reduce available reading time to the half hour before bed. And now the kids are up later - and my son needs defeating on Super Smash Bros - that time itself is getting squeezed.
I'm going to have to write more pro-doing nothing anti-reading pieces to create a high-flown justification for my ignorance.
Hi Will, Thank you for the clarity of your words to help us all fathom managing phone usage. As much as it can be a creative tool and many of us need instagram as a business card/portfolio etc it kills our creativity in many ways.
My big question is - do you manage to meditate without using an app?
Fully sympathise. I have given a lot of thought to ditching the smartphone but I really don't think it's compatible with the demands of my job. I am fortunate to not need to be onInstagram, but have many friends for whom that's the case and I can only imagine how difficult it is to balance.
Yes, I now meditate without an app.
I guess it depends what type of meditation you're going for. I know a lot of people enjoy those body scan / relaxation meditations, and I've always felt that it's much easier to do that while listening to something guided.
If you're going for the "focus on something, notice mind wander, return to focus" kind of meditation (which was my favourite) then from the start I just used ambient sound and a timer on my watch. Though sometimes I experimented with using clanging noises played via the phone, which helped in certain environments. Then after a few months I switched to the breath as focus.
In the early days I listened to a course by Jeff Warren on Calm, but I kind of used that for information, a little like listening to an audiobook.
Really enjoyed this one, Will! Looking forward to next week already:)
Thank you!
As am I
<feverishly starts writing>
Thank you for writing this Substack! Ive enjoyed following your journey. I've been inspired by you to take on a nuclear option: leaving my smartphone off for hours at a time and just checking every few hours, then immediately shutting off. Since I'm a parent I have an emergency dumb phone on at all time as an emergency back up.
People think I'm crazy having two phones, but when you are going up against Silicon Valley Phds working to addict you, you need extreme solutions.
Thank you so much for writing!
Absolutely fascinating - I really hope it works for you. Would genuinely love to hear - please let me know.
I'm a huge fan of this kind of approach - I once heard it described as intermittent digital fasting. Not only does it have super clear rules, I also suspect it gives the head time to clear which might result in 24/7 benefits in mood (with a little luck). Really hope it goes well.
I am certain it's not crazy. If self-control worked with phones, well.... well let's face it, it doesn't.
NB I accept it may not be much comfort to be told you're not crazy by someone who wears high vis :-)
LITERALLY your handle though?
IKR. It's the hardest working name on Substack.
I enjoy all your posts, but if some calamity were to come upon us all and I could help avert it by just picking one favourite, it would be this one. It is a vipassana post of the highest order, exquisitely formulated and yet accessible. Which btw is really difficult to do from the other side of any sort of awakening.
This is hugely appreciated. Honestly such a lovely comment to receive. Thank you.
And thank you for the last point too - I can see why people say things like "Just be", because that kind of is the whole thing. But that's no help, is it? And where is the fun in it? :-D