9 Comments
User's avatar
Ger's avatar
Sep 29Edited

I love this! I always intend to leave the phone outside the bedroom at night because I used to love reading. Now I scroll before I sleep, first thing in the morning, and if I wake in the night. That’s what I was doing when I found this article. In fact,

just before I had read a horrible racist comment at the end of a news report on a tragic event. Scrolling itself and the negativity we absorb can’t be good for our brains. Your article had the opposite effect and has inspired me to commit to at least 4 weeks of ‘no phone in the bedroom’ and see what happens…ps: I am also an aspiring writer, who doesn’t get to writing because I am so ‘busy’. Excited to see what happens..thank you!

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thank you! This made my morning!

I love that you found it while doing exactly the thing it’s about.

Four weeks of no phone in the bedroom is a brilliant experiment. Very good luck, and beware the Cloud of Nah :-D

Lovely to meet a fellow aspiring writer. May your extra time find its way onto the page.

Let me know how it goes.

C.R. Burgess's avatar

"The conversation ended and we didn’t know what to do. I had no social shield without my phone. And she could hardly pull out hers after talking to a man so anti-phone he was dressed like a total idiot."

This had me laughing out loud. I also didn't realize your commute is an hour each way. That's crazy. I'm not sure of the rules: do you read a book sometimes or are you just completely rawdogging your commute? This is coming from a guy who makes sure he takes his phone to do a wee...

Phone Free Will's avatar

That is high praise from the funniest new writer I have found so far on Substack. Thank you!

Yes! From Surbiton to Shoreditch. Sometimes I go via Oxford Circus, sometimes via Bank, but yes routinely an hour. If the trains are bad can be worse - I hit two hours once :-)

And yes just completely rawdogging, no book, no nothing. To be fair, it’s probably a touch easier for me because I have a little experience meditating so not sure I can hand on heart recommend it to a newcomer… Maybe start with 5 minutes!

Oh the phone wee - been there. You have a littleun, you probably earned it

Julianne Serpa's avatar

Do you have trouble feeling tired or falling asleep without conversation or reading to stimulate your mind? It sounds like you are falling into meditative states naturally because you’re not trying (trying can get in the way of shifting consciousness) - sounds like experiences of first/second jhana or pīti.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Hello! I generally sleep pretty well… if I don’t it’s usually to do with being busy in life rather than anything on the commute. (as far as I can tell!)

I should say, I had a little lead up to this in terms of meditation experience, so it’s not a straightforward answer! If you are interested, there are posts on the website listed under Back Story, but long story short I shuffled through quite a few meditation techniques including experiencing something that may or may not have been piti along the way.

Right now, Jargon-wise, I’d describe what I do now as alternating between non-dual mindfulness and forgetting to do that. Colloquially close to doing nothing!

It sounds like you have a practice… what’s yours like?

Julianne Serpa's avatar

I am a long time practitioner of various yoga traditions so pairing meditation with movement (especially dance!) is very natural to me. On the still end of things, yoga nidra is my go to but I have dabbled with other methods in the Buddhist tradition and modern secular mindfulness.

Matt Oldfield's avatar

About 15 years ago, I used to reverse commute from Waterloo to Guildford. The train was almost empty and quiet. I used to read a book a week.

Then I started picking up discarded newspapers and reading them instead of my book - What a waste of time.

After the Guildford gig, I went to NZ to work for 2 years, and this must be when the iPhone was released. I remember being amazed when people showed me the iPhone touchscreen and its functions. I was envious, but not enough to buy one.

(Before the iPhone, it was the BlackBerry crew who were glued to their phones - what were they doing? It was before social media; were they just addicted to email? I cannot remember now, but I suspect I was envious of them!

2026, I have a drawer with several old smartphones. I cannot drive without one (phone is key and Google Maps), cannot pay without one (G Pay), cannot get into a gig/train/plane without one (tickets).

I am already part cyborg; they just haven't found a way to implant the phone in me to complete the job.

I recently took someone's advice and deleted my X account - my worst habit. It is a start, but now I am using Substack more (Xlite?).

My brain is great at generating Cope for phone addiction (you are keeping yourself informed, etc.) - my brain seems petrified at the prospect of doing nothing - is it fear of boredom?. Quite strange, really, since I would say I am quite lazy, so doing nothing should be really easy for me.

All the best

Matt