22 Comments
User's avatar
Claire Foss's avatar

Amazing piece. I've also got into a lot of volunteering, and it really is amazing. I highly recommend the film 'Join or Die' - based on the book 'Bowling Alone' for lots on why social involvement is key to everything from health to the state of our democracy.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thank you!

And thank you, I will definitely add that to the list. And what's more I'd always meant to read Bowling Alone... it's one of those books you see cited so often.

Juliette Ryan's avatar

What a charming story! And I love the wholesome irony of how your charitable work freed you further from the digital bonds that got you into it in the first place. Perhaps the “actually” phone guilt can be a blessing in disguise; a way to bootstrap our way back into real life :).

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thank you!

Yes looking back I needed layers of layers upon guilt to agree so readily.

I've often found in our house if I were ever caught scrolling, I automatically pitched in more with housework for the next half hour. First irritation, then guilt, then making up for it!

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

I love this! I helped with Scouts too. Oh, how they loved the camps! I even slept (correction: didn’t sleep) on the cold hard floor of the Natural History Museum with our pack on a Dinosnores overnighter with Dippy. We all got the train from Carmarthen. ❤️

Phone Free Will's avatar

You too! It's brilliant isn't it!

Also... went to the sleepover at the Natural History Museum with our own two. Best thing we ever did together as a family I think.

Thank you for all the comments. I don't think it's your fault, I think this post is cursed due to strange technical problems. It's good though - Substack will think this one is popping off.

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

Sue Tabbitt's avatar

(I still can’t tie a knot or read a map!)

C.R. Burgess's avatar

I must apologize ahead of time that I always feel inspired to post long annoying replies here every week…

“We need the bonds of social obligation, the routine, the marathon we’ve signed up for, the gym group cheering us on, the concert we’re preparing for… maybe even the uniform.”

Couldn’t agree more. The trouble is that it’s so easy — so weirdly socially accepted — to opt out of all social obligation. In fact, you actually have to seek these things out and opt in. But, as you say, there’s always something “better” to be doing or some reason the village obligation is too much of a hassle, uniforms or whatever.

it seems insane that I would, for example, choose to spend an evening at home making myself feel bad scrolling than, like, throw on a uniform and go volunteer. But I actually stopped responding to a men’s group in town because I just couldn’t be arsed to do the work. Sell Christmas trees? Outside in the cold? For free? No thanks, I’ll stay at home and complain I’m lonely.

I feel like I’m not the only one.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Don't worry - if it becomes too much of a drag for me I can block you.

You make an excellent point once again. To a degree, I'm tapping into something bigger and pinning it on the phone. I read a book once (Fractured by Jon Yates) and it did a really powerful job of tracing the decline of togetherness. If I'm honest it largely pinned it on TV. But it surely must be that the phone is a huge factor too - if a study of one person is helpful, my phone use fell and I was able to witness my attitude changing before my very eyes. (Didn't control other variables).

Has to be said - selling Christmas trees outside in the cold does sound pretty terrible where you live. You probably made the right call there.

Thank you as ever. Your support from the start has made writing this feel less lonely.

Conor Heffernan's avatar

honestly, I know it is sometimes seen as clichéd, but Putnam's work on Bowling Alone in the 1990s has really resonated with me as I've hit my 30s.

Since having my son, I've completely changed my relationship with my phone. I made an effort to join clubs and set up associations, and even just sit idly without it because I don't want him to be a screen zombie and miss out on life.

Phone Free Will's avatar

I must read it! Someone else on here was talking about it too. I feel like I've read a 1,000 columns mentioning it over my life, but never the actual book.

And that's lovely! Children can help us see the challenge of the phone so clearly can't they.

Bess Sturman's avatar

This great piece takes me down memory lane to my own experience of our Scout Hut car park being fundamentally too small, and the wonderful wholesome memories my kids built there. Also absolutely spot-on about the rewarding experience of getting sucked into volunteering, and how we resist it. Oh, and that anger response when someone interrupts a good phone sesh. It needs a German word, if it doesn't already have one. Handywut?? (I don't speak German, so help me out if Google just made an arse of me)

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thanks so much for reading, and for sharing!

Volunteering is just part of that big ol' list stretching from gym membership all the way through to joining an orchestra. Should do all of it. I was so lucky to fall backwards into it.

And the irritation is so distinct isn't it. We first noticed it in our son when we stopped him playing on his Nintendo. He's much better now, but when he was younger he'd need a few minutes on the trampoline to burn off his post-screen irritation!

RetroDetox's avatar

How lucky for you to have found them!! :) AND I think this is also one answer to kids’ social media problems. As long as they have healthy social contacts in real life, they will never be fully sucked in by the online world. And even online bullying would cause less damage because they’d have a much healthier understanding of themselves. And of course, healthy real social life is just as good for adults… :D