18 Comments
User's avatar
RetroDetox's avatar

Oh dear, as if you were describing my own experiences here. :D Before I found out substack existed, I hadn't really used any form of social media. So doomscrolling for me was the news (mainly the bottom part with science updates and funnier pieces). Thankfully, I managed to replace that with actual social media now. Since then, I've been quite ignorant of the news... :)

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thank you for reading!

Substack is close to my only news source now. From it I have gathered there are midterms, thanks to the ticker, and also that there is such a thing as AI.

Bess Sturman's avatar

The science bits yes! And in today's news for those of you who aren't looking any more: Forget the midterms, this week they found a new realm called the ZEPTOVERSE using the Large Hadron Collider.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Well thank you, I wouldn't have known!

This is a problem. I am working through all the episodes of In Our Time and the physics ones will be out of date. Hmm.

RetroDetox's avatar

Thank you! I had to go and check it out, quite intriguing! :)

C.R. Burgess's avatar

Friend was over for coffee this past weekend. He asked me “what’s going on in the news?” We’re obviously not that good of friends because he didn’t know that I do not engage whatsoever with the news. I am the least “informed” guy there is. Except maybe for him. The reason he asked in the first place was that he also doesn’t read the news.

I’ve actually never been interested in the news, though. It’s kinda that simple for me. I never had to stop reading the news. I never started. My dad watches cable news or listens to news radio 24/7. My wife listens to a political podcast and reads The Guardian. Sometimes I envy people who know enough about events to form an opinion. Sometimes I feel guilty because I’ve been trained that knowing what’s going on is some moral obligation, even if it’s illogical.

I guess it can feel like ignoring the news is ignoring the suffering of others, but I’m curious as to what the civic, moral, or mental-health value is of simply knowing about a thing, especially if knowing is where my involvement ends. Is the whole news industrial complex there so we can raise social capital at dinner with friends and family by peacocking our specialized news knowledge??? Ooh, yes, I saw that story in The Times. How terrible! Did you see what’s happening with the _____ in ____???

Anyway, I gotta get back to reading a made up story about dragons. It’s actually really interesting, you see the king is trying to implement this tax policy in order to sanction…

Phone Free Will's avatar

You raise a really good question about the value (or not) of knowing sad things. I spent a long time grappling with these questions, interrogating the arguments on both sides, before finally realising that they were above my pay grade and really I should just write honestly about my failure.

Very amused to hear about your conversation with your friend... reminds me of my wife and I asking each other directions when we've just arrived in a city on holiday. Also trying to imagine what even the most avid newshound would say in response to "what's going on in the news?" :-)

All my best to dragonland, W.

Claire's avatar

Thanks for your response. I very much concur with your point about news being stultifying. We can think we are engaged in and connected to the world because we read or see lots about what's going on ‘out there’, but often the reality is that we pat ourselves on the back for being informed and knowledgeable, and then do absolutely bugger all to address what we've ‘learnt’!

By choosing only to focus on news items that really pique my interest, I can then look into them further and determine whether or not I can do anything to positively alter a situation that troubles or excites me.

I have used news stories as a springboard to volunteering many times. For example I volunteered with a group collecting and sending aid to Ukraine, and during the Covid pandemic I set up a weekly online quiz to help mitigate loneliness and isolation (in both myself and others). And when reports of Long Covid began to surface, I used the quiz as a way of raising awareness and funds for the ME Association who work with and for people who have CFS/ME or Long Covid.

When I hear a news item that evokes a strong emotional response in me, because I am selective about what ‘news’ I engage with, I usually have the energy to investigate what might be helpful and the lack of cynicism or defeatism to do what I can to help.

I am currently very engaged with reports on loneliness, isolation and a lack of human connection, especially where they relate to the Arts and humanities. These vital areas are constantly being squeezed out of our lives in a bid to further automate and commodify, and the effect on individuals and wider society is shocking. My current ‘pet project’ is creating opportunities for people (including me) to connect with the arts, humanities and entertainment in a way that brings people together to make friends, think more critically, and engage with different perspectives and ideas. The news and how we consume it can become an echo chamber where we end up only seeing what we already believe and only connecting with people who share our views and opinions. And I think that is dangerous. And VERY dull!

Phone Free Will's avatar

This is such a good strategy and much better than anything I came up with! I was all-or-nothing. Read everything did nothing. But choosing a few stories and actually following through on them is a great plan.

What is the arts project? Very interested to hear more. Loneliness is the side of phones I keep coming back to.

Claire's avatar

Knowing about 'the news' does not necessarily give us any power to affect change. More and more, news seems to be either about advertising something or about creating shock value in order to draw us in. Just this week, the radio news I heard all day led with a story about a private plane in the USA that had crashed killing all nine people on board. This is a very sad event, but I question it being the news story that is most important for British people to be made aware of. To me, it felt that a sensationalistic 'PLANE CRASH' headline was akin to a red top headline aimed at grabbing one's attention while walking by the newspaper stand.

I have not watched TV news, bought newspapers or scrolled Internet news sites for some time. I prefer to listen to the radio, engage with the music, the presenters, the other listeners, and to hear the brief news bulletin once an hour. This way I can then choose to look into a story in more detail if I feel the need to know more; all while getting on with other things that engage me creatively or require my attention domestically or administratively. Radio has always been a far more collaborative way of being part of the world than television or print, which both require us to sit still and go within ourselves rather than expand ourselves outwards to become part of the wider world (such as 'becoming' India, for example!)

I too felt (and maybe still feel) that I had a clear vision of what the answers to the ills of the world were, but age and experience have shown me that I have little ability to provoke meaningful change. And this can be frustrating and demoralising. But my ability to affect change within my own sphere is very real. Focusing on the micro can affect the macro. What's that phrase? 'Be the change you want to see in the world.' Large-scale media asks nothing of us. In fact, it perhaps wants us to do nothing. The cynic in me says it is a form of control. Choosing what news to engage with, trying to get a clear picture of what is important to me, and thinking about how I want to live according to my values and beliefs, gives me much more power as an individual to affect real change rather than becoming overwhelmed by the enormity of the problems facing us. Engagement is a choice, and choosing not no engage with every piece of media may well be the best way of focusing our attention and really making things better.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Thank you so much for reading! There was so much here that I identified with. Your plane crash point is a really good one and gets to the heart of what news is for... Yes we all make the citizen point, but there are so many things that are reported just because they have happened. Arguably they far, far outweigh the information one needs to be a good citizen.

And your last point is very well made. I wonder if you might enjoy next week's article - I ended up volunteering where I lived. It wasn't a conscious response to this, but over time I began to see its value in assuaging my unease.

I would be curious to know if there was a connection between the extent to which one follows news and the extent to which one takes positive action / volunteers. I found personally that the news stultified me into inaction!

Bess Sturman's avatar

I like that you had Radio 4 on all through your childhood. So did I. And your inner voice plotting to concur, I love that bit. I’d thought twice about sharing that I felt something odd in my tummy last Tuesday morning, and then you relay how you expanded into a whole country and became India, without any drugs. You’re really stacking up the benefits of meditation here! Yet I do worry a little for democracy if we all turn off the news. Yup, I do.

Phone Free Will's avatar

I found that piece fascinating - such an extraordinary experience. I remember thinking perhaps now because of where I've gone with all of this, maybe I've just closed myself off to something like that. I think I need to re-examine this, because weirdly meditation has made me more close-minded.

Except of course for those moments when I choose to become a country. :-)

Yeah, you must be right - if we all turned off the news democracy would be in big trouble. I always had the Washington Post masthead thing in my mind. Maybe it's like vaccinations, where you do it for yourself and for society too. I'm going to chew on that. And my unwitting closemindedness.

Bess Sturman's avatar

Thank you. I appreciate you taking the time to read that piece.

There is a well-documented phase in some models of consciousness transformation that matches this sensation of “closing-off” that you describe. Bear with me, and I will write about it, both the theory and how I experience it myself. In the meantime, I don’t think you have closed yourself off to anything. When I read your pieces, I see a mind hard at work, with a conscience too. Those two things are extremely precious, and powerful. Like democracy, they die in darkness.

Christine Ann O'Connell's avatar

Endless news checking as a certainty addiction is a great way to put it. I think the goal is coming back to the news without needing it to prove you right, and 283 hours of doing nothing on a commute in hi-vis sounds like excellent training for that lol

Phone Free Will's avatar

Ha thank you!

I think you might have something there about the being proved right thing... That's a really good thought

Looks like I might need a few more hundred hours before I've fully figured this one out... Thinking on it is moving at an alarmingly slow pace :-)

D. Maria's avatar

This is so relatable! I used to be such a news addict and, like you, I used it mostly as a distraction. I can’t say I don’t read the news anymore, but I’ve cut it down drastically -to the point that I found myself in a similar situation to the one you’ve described. I met with a friend last week and she brought up the story that was huge in the news recently about that girl who was raped at a campus a couple of weeks ago. I know it was huge in the news, but all I could recall was a glimpse of a headline. I knew no details, I basically knew nothing. Even my friend was surprised because usually I would be the one breaking all the news to everyone, like a CNN correspondent or something. It was a very strange realisation for me, and I’m not certain yet if it will make me go back to checking the news more often.

Phone Free Will's avatar

Yes that was me! I was always pretty sure I knew the news better than anyone else. I took a bit of pride in it, if I'm honest. I'd be sitting and listening to someone and secretly thinking I have read more on this than you.

It is a genuinely difficult one isn't it. I couldn't actually bring myself to describe what my friends were talking about at the start of the story, because there's no way of talking about it without implying that I don't care. I do care. But just didn't know. But then clearly don't care enough to know. But where does that end? And here we are. Don't know.

Spoiler alert for next week's, but ultimately I find myself volunteering more. It is in some weird way "buying" not having to read the news. But I have no idea if that is the right response.